Should Compounding Pharmacies Join a GPO? The Pros and Cons of Group Purchasing
Mar 13, 2025
Compounding pharmacies can save money and simplify operations by joining a Group Purchasing Organization (GPO). GPOs negotiate bulk discounts, reduce administrative costs, and improve supply chain management. But is it the right choice for your pharmacy? Here's a quick breakdown:
Key Benefits of GPOs:
Financial Savings: 10-18% cost reductions on average.
Streamlined Operations: Pre-negotiated contracts, cloud-based inventory tools, and simplified purchasing.
Regulatory Support: Assistance with compliance and quality standards.
Market Leverage: Increased buying power through collective membership.
Potential Downsides:
Less Flexibility: Standardized contracts may limit customization.
Membership Costs: Some GPOs charge fees or require minimum purchases.
Dependency: Relying on GPOs could reduce direct supplier relationships.
Independent Purchasing:
Pros: Full control over supplier choices and order customization.
Cons: Higher costs, more administrative work, and limited negotiation power.
Quick Comparison Table:
Aspect | GPO Membership | Independent Purchasing |
|---|---|---|
Cost Savings | 10-18% average savings | Higher costs overall |
Flexibility | Limited by GPO contracts | Fully customizable |
Administrative Work | Reduced | Increased |
Compliance Support | Provided by GPO | Self-managed |
Bottom Line: GPOs are ideal for cost savings and operational efficiency, while independent purchasing offers more flexibility and control. Evaluate your pharmacy’s needs, purchasing patterns, and compliance requirements to decide the best fit.
Related video from YouTube
1. Benefits of GPO Membership
Joining a Group Purchasing Organization (GPO) can help compounding pharmacies save money and simplify operations. According to CMS data, GPOs are expected to save the healthcare industry $456.6 billion between 2017 and 2026, highlighting their financial impact.
Financial Advantages: By leveraging collective purchasing power, GPOs negotiate better prices through bulk discounts. Member pharmacies often benefit from:
Up-front pricing discounts
Reduced administrative costs
Savings through standardized product options
In addition to these immediate savings, GPOs improve procurement processes with better supply chain management.
Supply Chain Improvements: GPOs offer cloud-based tools that make supply chain management more efficient for compounding pharmacies. Here's how:
Category | Features | Impact |
|---|---|---|
Inventory Management | Cloud tracking, auto-reordering | Avoids stock shortages or excess stock |
Order Processing | Centralized ordering system | Cuts down on time and errors |
Quality Control | Verified supplier networks | Ensures reliable product quality |
Expense Tracking | Analytics and forecasting tools | Supports smarter purchasing decisions |
These tools, backed by digital tracking and analytics, ensure a smooth and efficient supply chain process.
Transparent Cost Structure: Modern GPOs prioritize clarity in their fee structures:
Some GPOs offer free memberships, earning revenue through supplier fees.
Administrative fees are disclosed annually.
Any fees above 3% must be contractually outlined.
For both 503A and 503B pharmacies, streamlined supply chain management ensures consistent access to essential materials while maintaining strict quality standards.
2. Operating Without a GPO
Choosing independent purchasing gives compounding pharmacies full control over their supply chain but requires careful resource management. While GPOs simplify the process, going solo allows for a more tailored approach that some facilities prefer.
Direct Supplier Management
Independent purchasing means managing supplier relationships directly, which requires more effort but allows for greater customization. Pharmacies can:
Adjust orders to match their exact needs
Negotiate terms directly with manufacturers
Select specific products
Gain complete transparency in their supply chain
However, this approach takes time and procurement expertise to ensure compliance and maintain quality standards.
Cost Considerations
Operating independently often leads to higher costs and administrative work:
Cost Factor | Impact | Management Strategy |
|---|---|---|
Purchasing Power | Smaller order volumes result in higher costs | Strategic inventory planning |
Administrative Costs | More staff time needed for procurement tasks | Streamlined ordering processes |
DIR Fees | Payments tied to performance metrics | Focus on quality improvements |
Generic Drug Margins | Lower profit margins due to competition | Broaden revenue streams |
A survey found 63% of independent pharmacists see DIR fees as their biggest challenge. These financial hurdles highlight the importance of strong internal controls to meet compliance standards.
Regulatory Compliance
To navigate financial pressures, 503A and 503B facilities must maintain solid USP <797> compliance systems.
Quality Control Programs: Pharmacies need monitoring systems for environmental conditions, cleaning protocols, and staff training.
Documentation Management: Accurate records are critical, including:
Master Formulation Records
Compounding Records
Personnel training files
Quality assurance documents
"USP <797> forms the foundation for regulatory agencies, particularly state-level boards of pharmacy, to address unsafe compounding practices in pharmacies." - Wolters Kluwer
Supply Chain Visibility
Independent purchasing also ensures full transparency in sourcing and quality control. Pharmacies can:
Trace product origins
Verify ethical sourcing
Anticipate and manage risks
Maintain direct oversight of product quality
Though managing procurement without a GPO requires more resources, it offers the flexibility and control that can be essential for meeting specific operational needs.
Direct Comparison: GPO vs. Independent Purchasing
Compounding pharmacies face key differences when choosing between GPO membership and independent purchasing. Here's how they stack up:
Financial Impact
The financial differences between these two approaches are clear:
Aspect | GPO Membership | Independent Purchasing |
|---|---|---|
Annual Savings | Average $50,000 with programs like Pharmacy Select | Higher costs overall |
Negotiation Power | 10-18% savings on average compared to direct purchases | Limited ability to negotiate |
Generic Drug Pricing | Bulk pricing offers lower costs | Higher per-unit expenses |
Administrative Costs | Saves time for procurement staff | Requires more staff resources |
These numbers highlight the cost advantages of GPO membership, making it a strong consideration for pharmacies aiming to cut expenses.
Supply Chain Management
The procurement method directly affects how pharmacies handle supplier relationships and logistics:
Factor | GPO Model | Independent Model |
|---|---|---|
Supplier Access | Contracts with multiple vendors already negotiated | Direct relationships with manufacturers |
Order Flexibility | Standardized ordering processes | Customizable orders |
Contract Terms | Fixed through GPO agreements | Can be negotiated individually |
Supply Chain Visibility | Managed via GPO systems | Direct tracking and oversight |
Operational Considerations
GPO membership simplifies many processes but comes with pre-set contract terms that may reduce day-to-day flexibility.
Dan Fuchs of Dick's Pharmacy explains:
"If you're in the pharmacy business, you have to join a buying group or else you're just not going to make it. So, you might as well join the best one out there and I feel IPC is the best one out there."
Compliance and Oversight
Regulatory compliance is handled differently depending on the purchasing model:
Compliance Aspect | GPO Approach | Independent Approach |
|---|---|---|
Vendor Vetting | Vendors are pre-vetted through the GPO | Pharmacies must verify vendors themselves |
Fee Disclosure | Annual disclosure of administrative fees | Direct cost tracking required |
Quality Assurance | Standardized across the GPO network | Managed individually by the pharmacy |
Risk Management | Shared responsibility with the GPO | Fully self-managed by the pharmacy |
Market Position
Smaller compounding pharmacies often face challenges in staying competitive. GPO membership helps level the playing field. Danny Cottrell, RPh, of Medical Center Pharmacy, shares:
"Without them to do some negotiations for you on generic prices you would just be twisting in the wind. I don't see how a guy can be open without being in one."
Hybrid Solutions
A hybrid approach combines the benefits of GPO membership with the flexibility of independent purchasing. Pharmacies using this strategy can:
Take advantage of GPO pricing for high-demand items
Keep direct supplier relationships for specialized needs
Improve inventory management
Balance cost savings with operational control
Ultimately, the choice between GPO membership and independent purchasing depends on a pharmacy's specific needs, order volume, and operational goals.
Making Your Decision
Now that we've covered the pros and cons, here's a step-by-step guide to help you decide if joining a GPO is right for your pharmacy:
Step 1: Review Annual Purchasing Patterns
Take a close look at your pharmacy's purchasing habits. Here's a quick breakdown:
Category | What to Evaluate |
|---|---|
High-Volume Items | Monitor monthly usage and expenses |
Specialty Products | Identify unique sourcing needs |
Emergency Supplies | Check how often you run out |
Bulk Purchases | Assess your available storage space |
Step 2: Calculate Potential Savings
Look at both direct and indirect costs. GPO membership can lower expenses on purchases while also cutting down on administrative work and simplifying procurement processes.
Step 3: Evaluate Regulatory Impact
Consider how partnering with a GPO might affect your compliance and risk management efforts.
"The quality, safety, and appropriateness of the preparations remains the fiduciary responsibility of the dispensing pharmacy and pharmacist. This duty is not transferable."
Step 4: Assess Operational Effects
Think about how a GPO partnership could change your daily operations. Here are some key points:
Aspect | What to Consider |
|---|---|
System Integration | How it fits with ordering and inventory workflows |
Staff Training | Time needed to learn new processes |
Quality Control | How vendors are vetted and monitored |
Step 5: Determine Flexibility Needs
Decide if a mixed strategy works better for your pharmacy. For example:
Use GPO contracts for standard supplies while keeping relationships with specialty vendors.
Take advantage of GPO analytics tools to guide purchasing decisions.
Join regional purchasing committees for additional input.
Step 6: Review Contract Terms
Carefully examine the details of any GPO contract, including:
Membership fees and how payments are structured.
The length of the contract and termination policies.
Minimum purchase commitments.
Reporting requirements.
How much freedom you have in selecting vendors.
For more resources, check out 503Pharma's educational platform.